Rose starts off by stating that he had always been a fan of the horror genre and of Barker’s work. Poul talks about how the project came together. Barker examines the Candyman mythology and Madsen, a native of Chicago, talks about how she prepared for the role. Each participant was recorded separately and edited together so that there is no dead air. This is a very interesting commentary packed with factoids (i.e. Sandra Bullock was almost cast in Madsen’s role) that fans of the movie will thoroughly enjoy.

I agree with the above review. Normally, I prefer the cast and crew together for a commentary. Sometimes the "multiple-interview" format is in no way scene-specific.
This commentary differs in that all participants are allowed to define themes in the movie as well as dish on behind-the-scenes aspects for specific moments.
Clive Barker's "Boogeyman" insights in modern culture are interesting and Virginia comes off as the chick you'd love to share a bottle of Pinot with from "Sideways."
Great commentary, Definitely worth purchasing the Special Edition.

Excellent edited commentary by a very intelligent cast and crew. Not always scene specific, so it was actually an interesting listen while doing cardio at the gym.

I like these recorded separately commentaries, rather than cramming everybody in a room and them talking over each other and gushing over how "Great" everything is. None of that ass kissing here. Thank God.