[ratethatcommentary.com]
Login | Register


I, Robot (2004)

View at IMDB

NOTE: The original Region 1 (US/Canada) DVD release only had the Proyas/Goldsman commentary track. The May 2005 2-disc "Collector's Edition" Region 1 release as well as the original Region 2 and Region 3 2-disc special editions have all three commentaries.

Commentaries on this disc:

Commentary 1: Director Alex Proyas and screenwriter Akiva Goldsman Rating:7.6/10 (5 votes) [graph]Login to vote or review
Reviewed by directorscut on March 22nd, 2005:Find all reviews by directorscut
An okay commentary. Goldsman sounds like a regular hack who knows only what he has learned from “Screenwriting 101 for Dummies”. Proyas offers the real information here. The commentary was recorded six weeks before release and just before the test screening so he is quite anxious about the fate of his film. He sheds light on how utterly moronic (in terms of creativity) men in suits are. Apparently they were constantly at odds with him as the film was considered “too intelligent for a mass audience”. How wonderful it is to know executives give audiences such large credit. With this type of attitude towards audiences the prospects of good and intelligent cinema coming from Hollywood is becoming smaller and smaller.
Reviewed by pat00139 on March 5th, 2007:Find all reviews by pat00139
These two guys don’t seem to be together, but if they were they’d probably praise each other endlessly. The writer keeps almost completely to story elements. The character stuff is something else he talks about a lot. Some of the stuff he says is pretty obvious if you’ve seen the movie, but other things are quite interesting. They talk about Dr. Calvin’s back-story and Mr. Goldsman’s thoughts about it are probably the most interesting thing. I do have to say that Mr. Goldsman’s thoughts on action should’ve been implemented in ‘Batman Forever’ and ‘Batman & Robin’ (both of which he wrote), and maybe those ideas would’ve seemed more credible coming from him. As for Mr. Proyas, he talks a lot about the story and production in the beginning and then after a while he talks about the technical things. Hearing Mr. Proyas bitch about money men is entertaining, and his talks about the translight that was bad and other mistakes is also nice to hear. The director talks a little about the effects and how they did them. Pretty hefty stuff. Mr. Goldsman seems to be a little more enthusiastic than Mr. Proyas, but they’re both as interesting. Believe it or not, they even talk about budgetary constraints. The reasons and the personal theories the two guys express are far more interesting than the talk about the movie itself. This is a nice track with some funny and informative bits, but not a classic. Something that could have been done better is that the commentary was recorded a whole six weeks before the theatrical release, so, I think, the effects weren’t finished. Overall, it’s a nice track.
Commentary 2: Production designer Patrick Tatopoulous, editor Richard Learoyd, visual effects supervisor John Nelson, associate producer John Kilkenny, animation supervisor Andrew Jones, visual effects supervisors Brian Van’t Hul, Joe Letteri, Erik Nash, Dale Fay, Lead CG supervisor Eric Saindon, and compositing supervisor Erik Winquist Rating:7.0/10 (1 vote) [graph]Login to vote or review
Reviewed by pat00139 on March 2nd, 2006:Find all reviews by pat00139
Most of these guys are alone, but two pairs of them are together. I think John Nelson and maybe Brian Van’t Hul are together, I think. The other pair is Patrick Tatopoulous and, say, maybe, Richard Learoyd. In any case, the track is very interesting. For a movie this size and this complex, there’s virtually no end to the amount of information you can have. Indeed, they pretty much never stop talking. The editing in the track is very nice, so the flow is never strange. You get tidbits of information like nine lighting passes for the NS-5s were used, and you get to hear about a neat-o machine called the ‘encodi-cam’, or something like that. If you’re interested in any kind of technical aspects of filmmaking, be sure to listen to this. All the complex shots and CG images are all explained in detail. Very nice technical track.
Commentary 3: Composer Marco Beltrami (with isolated score) Rating:7.0/10 (1 vote) [graph]Login to vote or review
Reviewed by pat00139 on March 2nd, 2006:Find all reviews by pat00139
If you’ve heard one composer commentary, you’ve sort of heard them all. That doesn’t mean it’s boring. Mr. Beltrami enlightens you about how he got started in music and about how he works. He talks about his childhood and getting into movies. Talking about himself and how he started, you know this guy is no joke. He’s good. Anyway, he talks about his process of work and how little time he had to work on this movie. He basically wrote all the time he worked on the movie and had no time with the orchestra (or at least that’s what I understood of it). It’s nice and when he’s not talking his nice score comes out of the speakers, making you hear things you missed while watching the movie. It’s a nice track.