[ratethatcommentary.com]
Login | Register


Sin City (2005)

View at IMDB

NOTE: These commentaries are only available on the December 2005 "Recut and Extended" DVD. The original "Sin City" DVD did not have any commentary tracks.

Commentaries on this disc:

Commentary 1: Directors Robert Rodriguez and Frank Miller Rating:7.6/10 (18 votes) [graph]Login to vote or review
Reviewed by The Cubist on December 12th, 2005:Find all reviews by The Cubist
The two men take us through the production process and their experiences making the movie. A lot of time is spent discussing the cast’s performances and Miller talks about how nervous he was on the first day that he had to direct Bruce Willis. Rodriguez is a gracious collaborator and praises Miller for teaching him a lot about directing. This is a fantastic track that is jam-packed with great insights for fans of the comic book to enjoy listening to.
Reviewed by Bickle, T. on May 26th, 2009:Find all reviews by Bickle, T.
If you're a fan of the film, then this track is a must. It's really cool to know which actors filmed together and which didn't. Rodriguez is always a good, enthusiastic speaker.
Commentary 2: Directors Robert Rodriguez, with Quentin Tarantino on "The Big Fat Kill" and Bruce Willis on "That Yellow Bastard" Rating:7.2/10 (13 votes) [graph]Login to vote or review
Reviewed by The Cubist on December 12th, 2005:Find all reviews by The Cubist
Rodriguez flies solo for the first bit as he goes into the more technical details of the filmmaking process. He would make an excellent teacher as he is never bogged down with hard to understand concepts, instead making them understandable to the layman. As always, he is an engaging and enthusiastic presence and once “The Big Fat Kill” segment starts up he is joined by Quentin Tarantino who shares his thoughts. After Tarantino exits, Bruce Willis comes on for “That Yellow Bastard” and speaks about how he got involved, his love of film noir and so forth. This track is a fantastic lesson on how to make movie outside of the Hollywood system.
Reviewed by reidca on January 28th, 2008:Find all reviews by reidca
This commentary has dead spots and there’s too much narrating of the onscreen action, but they drop a couple of whoppers: Rodriguez almost did a remake of Kiss Me Deadly in 1997 with Michael Mann producing prior to coming up with this concept; Tarantino was inspired by the lighting in Argento's Suspiria and Inferno for his scene; and Coppola came to watch them film on green screen and came away thinking “this was my dream for Zoetrope” (re digital cinema).
Commentary 3: Austin Premiere Audience Reaction Rating:5.0/10 (11 votes) [graph]Login to vote or review
Reviewed by The_Phantom_Menace on August 26th, 2006:Find all reviews by The_Phantom_Menace
Not actually a commentary, but a recording of the crowd for the Austin, Tx premiere. Interesting way to attemp to recreate a theater like experience in your own home.
Reviewed by TommyT on September 27th, 2006:Find all reviews by TommyT
Yup, not really a commentary but listening to the audience reaction is fascinating & funny. One of the best DVD bonus features I've come across.
Reviewed by Lord Bullingdon on October 12th, 2006:Find all reviews by Lord Bullingdon
Listening to the raucous laughter and "oooohhhh" of excitement when Yellow Basted gets his comeuppance does not sound revolutionary. It is. Recording the audience during the Austin premiere and releasing it with the super special edition of Sin City, Robert Rodriguez's is on to something. So much so that I would say EVERY event film should feel obligated to release their films with an audience reaction commentary. And why not? For those of us who are socially inept and/or sick of going to the movie theaters just to be annoyed, this is the answer. I've been thinking about this type of commentary for years and watching it realized makes me proud that commentaries are indeed evolving and exploring new approaches.
Reviewed by Dang on May 15th, 2008:Find all reviews by Dang
Absolutely worthless waste of time. Can I give a commentary a negative score? This "commentary" is even more pointless than the Bowling for Columbine commentary that was done by a bunch of interns. Watching paint dry is more productive than listening to this "commentary," because it means you actually painted something.