[ratethatcommentary.com]
Login | Register


Reservoir Dogs (1991)

NOTE: These commentaries are only available on the Reservoir Dogs 10th Anniversary Special Edition.

Commentaries on this disc:

Commentary 1: Film critics Amy Taubin, Peter Travers, Emanuel Levy (selected scenes only) Rating:5.1/10 (7 votes) [graph]Login to vote or review
Reviewed by Brian Thibodeau on May 3rd, 2004:Find all reviews by Brian Thibodeau
The critics track on Reservoir dogs really offers nothing over the obvious and, naturally, only reinforces the subjective nature of film criticism, whether its practiced in national film magazines or on internet forums, and leading to the big question of should critics (as opposed to historians) should be able to enshrine such thoughts for all time on little plastic discs. All three critics take the "this is my interpretation" route, which is inherently subjective (and only mildly interesting) and which speaks to a certain arrogance rarely found on the tracks provided by proper film historians on older films. Little technical information can be found on this track; just pretentious theorizing.
Reviewed by psychedelic on March 26th, 2006:Find all reviews by psychedelic
Plus what is up with Amy Taubin going on about how she wants to screw Eminem? This has NOTHING to do with Reservoir Dogs. Please keep your irrelevant fetishes at home Ms. Taubin.
Reviewed by aph86 on December 26th, 2006:Find all reviews by aph86
What the fuck is the point of this commentary. They don't say anything that means anything at all. Just fucking stupid.
Reviewed by criterion_hunter on March 26th, 2008:Find all reviews by criterion_hunter
While you may agree or disagree with what these critics say, you cannot deny their intrigue. This trio of commentaries just prooves what Tarantino was saying in the feature-length commentary, how someone in the audience will have seen a slightly different movie than the person sitting beside them. A great film, a great piece of art, is open to interpretation. A nice supplement.
Commentary 2: Director Quentin Tarantino, producer Lawrence Bender, executive producer Monte Hellman, director of photography Andrezj Sekla, editor Sally Menke, and actors Tim Roth, Chris Penn, Michael Madsen and Kirk Baltz (edited together from interviews) Rating:7.1/10 (8 votes) [graph]Login to vote or review
Reviewed by criterion_hunter on March 26th, 2008:Find all reviews by criterion_hunter
I am like many who found a commentary track consisting of interviews highly suspect. But, this edited track is no different than a Criterion commentary. Let me just say that Artisan has done a terrific job keeping the discussions scene-specific. Obviously, Tarantino is in the center ring here. His brilliance as a writer comes through about a quarter of the way into the track where he furiously defends his linear style. "I write like a novelist. Reservoir Dogs is divided into chapters. I will @#$%ing tell you when its a flashback." He also sheds some intriguing light on why eastern audiences understand the film's last couple minutes compared to western audiences. The other contributors, including many of the actors, are a real treat and offer very amusing anecdotes about the production. A great commentary track!
Reviewed by Station51 on October 7th, 2016:Find all reviews by Station51
I really enjoyed this commentary. It's been edited well enough that the piecemeal composition of interviews and commentary from different people add to a comprehensive whole to give you a look at the film from a wide variety of angles. When I listen to a commentary of a film I like I want as much information as possible. If it's not a great picture, I at least want to entertained. The amount of pertinent information from everybody ends up being informative and more than entertaining enough. Excellent.