Login
|
Register
Search
:
(e.g.,
Lord of the Rings
, or
Joss Whedon
, or
director of photography
)
Home
Add a new title
Best commentary tracks (top 100)
Worst commentary tracks
Browse all titles
Site statistics
FAQ
Contact us
What a Girl Wants
(2003)
Commentaries on this disc:
Commentary 1:
Director Dennie Gordon, and screenwriters Jenny Bicks and Elizabeth Chandler
Rating:6.0/10 (1 vote) [
graph
]
Login
to vote or review
Reviewed by CaptHayfever on August 4th, 2004
:
Find all reviews by CaptHayfever
It's not a BAD track, persay, but not an expecially GOOD one either. It's always nice to hear from the screewriters, who are so often overlooked in Hollywood, but unfortunately these two seem to be having a private conversation filled with inside stories that they don't bother explaining to us. The director is also excluded from this conversation, since she is in a completely different place, unable to hear the writers or be heard by them. I always hate when this happens, because it guarantees a nice big load of repetition and very poor interaction, and this was no exception. Dennie gets a 6 for being mildly interesting, Jenny & Elizabeth each get 5's.
Commentary 2:
Actor Amada Bynes
Rating:8.0/10 (1 vote) [
graph
]
Login
to vote or review
Reviewed by CaptHayfever on August 4th, 2004
:
Find all reviews by CaptHayfever
Bynes's commentary debut goes extremely well for the young actress, as she is entertaining, informative, and just a wee-bit self-depricating to boot. I liked it.